detroit era jla

[curefreak]

this has been on my conscience for a long time but i feel like aquaman was never held responsible for abondoning those kids especially without saying goodbye or nothing.
i know j'onn took over but he wasnt the one who founded them and left them high and dry:mad:
i mean i feel like someone should have been held responsible for that whole disaster.
call this fanboy whining if you will but its just my opinion

[matewan1990]

this has been on my conscience for a long time but i feel like aquaman was never held responsible for abondoning those kids especially without saying goodbye or nothing.
i know j'onn took over but he wasnt the one who founded them and left them high and dry:mad:
i mean i feel like someone should have been held responsible for that whole disaster.
call this fanboy whining if you will but its just my opinion

I think the whole reasoning behind Aquaman leaving and J'Onn taking over was that this was an ALL-NEW League and J'Onn was to be its only connection to the past.
What about Zatanna? She left the group high and dry, too. And what about Batman, who was with the Detroit League for a little while?
Shouldn't those heroes be held responsible, too?
Really, though, why should Aquaman be held responsible since these characters existed long after he left?
I loved the Detroit League. I've been a big fan of theirs since I read their exploits and the destruction of that particular incarnation of the League since I first read them 20 years ago.
I thought that was a great way to end a League that almost NO ONE BUT ME liked. They battled for their place in JLA history, they saved lives and served humanity and died in battle. What a great trade paperback that would make...
Mike B.

[curefreak]

I think the whole reasoning behind Aquaman leaving and J'Onn taking over was that this was an ALL-NEW League and J'Onn was to be its only connection to the past.
What about Zatanna? She left the group high and dry, too. And what about Batman, who was with the Detroit League for a little while?
Shouldn't those heroes be held responsible, too?
Really, though, why should Aquaman be held responsible since these characters existed long after he left?
I loved the Detroit League. I've been a big fan of theirs since I read their exploits and the destruction of that particular incarnation of the League since I first read them 20 years ago.
I thought that was a great way to end a League that almost NO ONE BUT ME liked. They battled for their place in JLA history, they saved lives and served humanity and died in battle. What a great trade paperback that would make...
Mike B.
i was a fan of them too and its nice to see someone else is too the reason im singleing out aquaman cause he was there founder and leader and he left them high and dry (no pun intended)to find his wife.

[marshal99]

The funny thing was , Aquaman disbanded the old justice league to form his own poor third rate version because he wanted full time commitment from the members , instead he's the first to leave them high and dry. :D

Batman only joined after martian manhunter begged him to and he joined for his own agenda .

[Paul Newell]

Hang on, didn't he leave to find his wife who had disappeared? Pretty good reason, it's not like he just ditched 'em to hang out with seahorses.

[curefreak]

Hang on, didn't he leave to find his wife who had disappeared? Pretty good reason, it's not like he just ditched 'em to hang out with seahorses.
but he never said goodbye or gave a reason and he never came back.

[curefreak]

The funny thing was , Aquaman disbanded the old justice league to form his own poor third rate version because he wanted full time commitment from the members , instead he's the first to leave them high and dry. :D

Batman only joined after martian manhunter begged him to and he joined for his own agenda .
what was his agenda?

[marshal99]

what was his agenda?

No idea since i do not follow JL detroit but i read the issue he came back in , issue 250 where all the big guns (supes,gl,bats etc) came back to help the JL detroit and it was hinted when he joined towards the end that he has a personal agenda for joining.

[curefreak]

No idea since i do not follow JL detroit but i read the issue he came back in , issue 250 where all the big guns (supes,gl,bats etc) came back to help the JL detroit and it was hinted when he joined towards the end that he has a personal agenda for joining.
well i remember it being j'onn practically begging bats to train them in self defense.

[marshal99]

well i remember it being j'onn practically begging bats to train them in self defense.

Okay , i check out the issue. After j'ohn ask him , bats turned him down and then Gypsy goes teary eyed and beg him and then bats said yes and he said that he will give it a year.
And then in bats own thoughts after that "Gypsy thinks she convinced me ..... but i have my own reason for rejoining the league. And when i reveal those reasons, she'll be very SURPRISED".

Batman has his own agenda , but i have no clue what that is. :)

[curefreak]

Okay , i check out the issue. After j'ohn ask him , bats turned him down and then Gypsy goes teary eyed and beg him and then bats said yes and he said that he will give it a year.
And then in bats own thoughts after that "Gypsy thinks she convinced me ..... but i have my own reason for rejoining the league. And when i reveal those reasons, she'll be very SURPRISED".

Batman has his own agenda , but i have no clue what that is. :)
typical bat dick always looking out for himself:rolleyes:
still i blame aquaman and not because i dont like him but i think someone should be held responsible why i choose aquaman is he founded the team and lead them originally.
so i feel like he should have owned up to his responsiblity.

[caats19]

how vibe and steel die? didn't they all die or something.

[curefreak]

how vibe and steel die? didn't they all die or something.
all cept for gypsy (dont ask me why she was spared she had the lamest powers and very little history to care about)

[marshal99]

how vibe and steel die? didn't they all die or something.

Killed by Professor Ivo's robots , Vibe got strangled to death , Steel got damaged beyond repair though still technically alive until Despero came calling much later in the JLI and destroyed his life support.

Gypsy managed to survive when the third rate JLA disbanded , although her parents were killed by Despero much later who had came looking for revenge against the remaining members of the justice league detroit.

[curefreak]

Killed by Professor Ivo's robots , Vibe got strangled to death , Steel got damaged beyond repair though still technically alive until Despero came calling much later in the JLI and destroyed his life support.

Gypsy managed to survive and then the third rate JLA disbanded , although her parents were killed by Despero who came looking for revenge against the remaining members of the justice league detroit.was vixen new to the comics when she came on the detroit league? i cant clearly recall.

[marshal99]

was vixen new to the comics when she came on the detroit league? i cant clearly recall.

Apparently not
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vixen_(comics)

[curefreak]

Apparently not
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vixen_(comics)
im beginning to think that ed mcguiness has got to be one of the worst artists ever.