PDA

View Full Version : Canadian Anti-Smoking Icon Dies of Lung Cancer from 2nd Hand Smoke


Lone Ranger
05-24-2006, 07:41 AM
This is beyond tragic.

I could not imagine working in anything but a smoke-free environment.

Her successful claim for benefits will likely have as much impact as any of her media appearances.

The changes in Ontario over the past couple of decades have been incredible (although some smokers might think otherwise).

Waitress who got cancer from second-hand smoke dies

Canadian Press

Toronto — Heather Crowe, known as the face of Canada's anti-smoking movement, has succumbed to lung cancer in Ottawa at the age of 61.
The long-time waitress, who never smoked, is widely known for television ads in which she describes how she contracted cancer from second-hand smoke at the restaurant where she worked for 40 years.

She was diagnosed in 2002, fighting the cancer with chemotherapy, radiation and steroids before it went into remission. However, she learned last August that the cancer had spread and she was losing her battle with the disease.
Ms. Crowe's passing comes just one week before the Smoke Free Ontario Act comes into effect in Ontario.

The act will ban any smoking in any enclosed public places and will add restrictions to the promotion, handling and display of cigarettes in stores.
Jim Watson, the Liberal MPP for Ottawa-West-Nepean, was a frequent customer at the restaurant where Ms. Crowe worked and called her the "matriarch of the anti-smoking movement."

He said on Monday that Ms. Crowe told him she really wanted to live to see the anti-smoking legislation come into effect.

"It's very sad that she's not going to be here to see it, but she should be very happy that because of her influence, Ontarians will be able to breathe easier as a result of the legislation on May 31," said Mr. Watson.
Mr. Watson said Ms. Crowe was an unlikely activist. "She fell into this anti-smoking passion because she experienced first-hand what so many people have suffered over the years. "She was a very thoughtful, compassionate individual who was not fancy or glib. She was very sincere in her approach and she just wanted to ensure that no one else had to suffer like she had to suffer as a result of exposure to second-hand smoke."

Premier Dalton McGuinty presented Ms. Crowe with an award named in her honour last December. The Heather Crowe Award will recognize the efforts of individuals and organizations in promoting a smoke-free Ontario. Ms. Crowe was the first person to win a claim with the Ontario Workers Safety and Insurance Board for full compensation because her cancer was caused by occupational exposure to cigarette smoke.

"'If I'd lost my hand at work they'd have paid me," she once said of the compensation award. "So if they're going to take chunks out of my lungs, why wouldn't I be entitled [to benefits]?"

howyadoin
05-24-2006, 12:02 PM
What, no bullshit responses about how second-hand smoke doesn't really cause cancer?

Michael P
05-24-2006, 12:02 PM
What, no bullshit responses about how second-hand smoke doesn't really cause cancer?
Those are in the other thread.

Matt Algren
05-24-2006, 12:08 PM
Those are in the other thread.
...and not so much bullshit.

Shellhead
05-24-2006, 12:20 PM
...and not so much bullshit.

And not so much bullshit as really convenient delusions.

Xetal
05-24-2006, 12:43 PM
Beyond tragic? That she died?

In a way, but without the tragedy she wouldn't have been the force she was. As usual, it's what you make of the hand you're dealt, and she made a triumph of it.

I've been a smoker for almost forty years, but it's people like Ms Crowe who made me behave responsibly when it comes to non-smokers' rights not to have to share what I inflict on myself.

fly on the wall
05-24-2006, 12:54 PM
What, no bullshit responses about how second-hand smoke doesn't really cause cancer?

Did Dana Reeves work as a waitress? The woman's lung cancer could be unrelated to the smoky environment she worked in. Some people just get lung cancer for no apparent reason.

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for smoking bans in the workplace. One of the things I loved about working in science was the complete ban on cigs as far back as 1983. Before that I had office jobs and had to fight with my smoking coworkers to get them to stop.

Mind you I was not afraid of second hand smoke causing lung cancer, I just found the smoke irritating. It was a real hassle to constantly fight with them.

I'm not saying that second hand smoke doesn't cause lung cancer, maybe it does. But I doubt it and have never been shown hard data that it does.

If 66% of lifetime smokers do not get lung cancer, why would anyone get cancer from a much diluted smoke exposure of second hand smoke.

66% of lifetime smokers, breathing the raw hot stuff right into their lungs all day long don't get cancer.

But someone exposed to next to no smoke does?

I'm still skeptical.

Sorry.

I will admit that the fact that people have accepted second hand smoke as being dangerous has gotten annoying smokers out of the workplace and restaurants, but still that doesn't prove second hand smoke is dangerous, just a useful tool against smokers in general.

Most of the smokers I know that quit did so because all the new rules made it inconvenient to smoke. Standing outside in the cold and wind and rain reeducated them.

Nick Soapdish
05-24-2006, 01:20 PM
You're kidding me!

A full third of lifetime smokers develop lung cancer?

Honestly, I assumed that it was lower. (Then again, the rate of lung cancer among non-smokers might be a lot higher than I imagined as well.)

At any rate, the human body is kind of complicated. It has a lot of parts and most of them are in widely varying circumstances. Meaning that different people respond differently to certain biological stimuli thanks to their genetics and other environmental factors. You aren't going to get a 100% correlation for anything short of a bullet to the brain or dipping people in acid.